PlayerPlan vs TrainHeroic: Which Is Right for Football S&C Coaches?
Two Platforms, Two Very Different Jobs
TrainHeroic has been around since 2012. It's part of Peaksware Holdings, has about 24 employees, and calls itself "The #1 Strength and Conditioning Software Platform." It serves NFL teams, Olympic programmes, college athletics, CrossFit boxes, and independent coaches selling programmes through its marketplace. It has 64,000 Instagram followers and genuine credibility in the strength training world.
I built PlayerPlan because I was an S&C coach working with football players, and TrainHeroic -- for all its strengths -- doesn't understand what that actually involves. It doesn't know what MD-3 means. It can't track what your players are doing at club training. It has no concept of in-season vs. off-season periodisation. Its exercise library and community features are built around CrossFit WODs and powerlifting PRs, not pitch-to-gym transfer sessions and Copenhagen protocols.
TrainHeroic is a good platform. It just wasn't built for what you do.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | PlayerPlan | TrainHeroic |
|---|---|---|
| Session builder | ✓ Yes (drag-drop, supersets, circuits, tempo) | ✓ Yes (with Metcon logging) |
| Exercise library | 600+ (football/S&C focused) | Large library with demo videos |
| Multi-week periodisation (phases, deloads) | ✓ Yes (Base/Build/Peak/Taper/In-Season/Off-Season) | ✗ No (generic programme blocks) |
| Energy system builder (GPS velocity zones) | ✓ Yes (6-zone model) | ✗ No |
| Match-day framework awareness | ✓ Yes (MD-3 to MD+2) | ✗ No |
| Position-specific programming | ✓ Yes (GK, Defender, Midfielder, Forward) | ✗ No |
| ACWR load monitoring | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Wellness check-ins | ✓ Yes (sleep, energy, soreness, stress, mood) | Readiness questionnaire (single template) |
| External training load tracking | ✓ Yes (players log club sessions) | ✗ No |
| Protocol management (rehab, return-to-play) | ✓ Yes (with player check-ins) | ✗ No |
| Performance testing with trend charts | ✓ Yes (6 categories) | Limited (PR tracking) |
| 1RM / maxes tracking | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes (working maxes) |
| AI assistant | ✓ Yes (football-specific) | ✗ No |
| AI-generated insights | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Competition/match tracking | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Player sharing (no login) | ✓ Yes (share link) | ✗ No (athletes must create accounts + download app) |
| Benchmarking (position/age-group) | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Marketplace (sell programmes) | ✗ No | ✓ Yes (two-sided marketplace with revenue sharing) |
| Leaderboards | ✗ No | ✓ Yes (daily, filterable) |
| Team chat | ✗ No | ✓ Yes (TH Chat with GIFs, reactions) |
| PR celebrations | ✗ No | ✓ Yes (automatic recognition) |
| Wearable integrations | ✗ No | Limited (Apple Health nutrition only) |
| Public API | ✓ Yes (documented edge functions) | ✗ No (frequently requested, not available) |
Pricing: The Maths That Matters
TrainHeroic uses per-athlete tiered pricing. PlayerPlan is a flat $39/mo for up to 20 players. Here's what that looks like at different roster sizes:
| Roster Size | TrainHeroic | PlayerPlan (Pro) | Difference | Per-Player (TH) | Per-Player (PP) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 player | $9.99/mo | $39/mo | TH saves $29/mo | $9.99 | $39.00 |
| 5 players | $17.99/mo | $39/mo | TH saves $21/mo | $3.60 | $7.80 |
| 10 players | $34.99/mo | $39/mo | TH saves $4/mo | $3.50 | $3.90 |
| 15 players | $34.99/mo | $39/mo | TH saves $4/mo | $2.33 | $2.60 |
| 20 players | $44.99/mo | $39/mo | PP saves $6/mo | $2.25 | $1.95 |
Let me be honest: if you have 5 players and all you want is a workout logger, TrainHeroic at $17.99/mo is the cheaper option by a good margin. That's real.
The question is whether a workout logger is actually what you need. At $17.99/mo, TrainHeroic gives you session delivery, a readiness questionnaire, and PR tracking. It doesn't give you periodisation, load monitoring, match-day frameworks, injury protocols, energy system design, or AI insights. PlayerPlan at $39/mo gives you all of that. The $21/mo difference at 5 players is about $5/week. Whether that's worth it depends entirely on whether those features matter to your coaching.
At 15+ players, the pricing converges. At 20, PlayerPlan is cheaper. And the price never jumps -- $39/mo at 4 players or 20. TrainHeroic's 11-tier pricing table means your bill changes every time your roster grows past a threshold. Coaches with fluctuating rosters pay unpredictably.
One more thing on pricing: TrainHeroic charges $9.99/month per additional assistant coach. PlayerPlan doesn't have assistant coach accounts yet, but the single-coach price includes everything.
Where TrainHeroic Wins
Credit where it's due:
1. The Marketplace is genuinely unique. TrainHeroic's two-sided marketplace lets coaches sell training programmes to athletes they've never met. It's passive income -- you build a programme once and sell it indefinitely. Mike Boyle sells soccer performance programmes there. Independent coaches use it to build a revenue stream beyond 1-on-1 coaching. No other S&C platform has anything like this. PlayerPlan doesn't have a marketplace and isn't building one.
2. Community and competition features. Daily leaderboards, PR celebrations, team accountability, TH Chat with reactions and GIFs. For coaches whose athletes thrive on competition and social engagement, TrainHeroic creates daily engagement loops that keep athletes opening the app. PlayerPlan's player view is functional, but it's not gamified.
3. Expert-authored content. TrainHeroic's blog, "The Training Lab," has genuinely good content about periodisation, programme design, and coaching methodology. It's written by real S&C coaches, not marketers. Some of their articles are worth reading regardless of what platform you use.
4. Working maxes and percentage-based training. TrainHeroic has a mature system for managing working maxes and auto-calculating percentage-based prescriptions. PlayerPlan tracks maxes too, but TrainHeroic's implementation has had more years to be refined.
Where PlayerPlan Wins
1. Football-specific everything. TrainHeroic's DNA is CrossFit and powerlifting. The language, the features, the community -- it's built around WODs, Metcons, and PRs on the back squat. There's no match-day framework. No position-specific programming. No fixture-list awareness. No in-season periodisation. If you're programming around a Saturday fixture and need your Tuesday session to account for what happened on the pitch at the weekend, TrainHeroic doesn't help you.
2. App stability. TrainHeroic's mobile app has well-documented stability issues -- users report freezes, login loops, and occasional data loss in app store reviews. PlayerPlan is a web app -- no download, no app store issues, no "the app crashed and I lost my workout" messages from your players.
3. Load monitoring and external loads. Session RPE, session load, ACWR tracking -- and critically, external training load logging where your players report what they did at club training. Your left-back played 80 minutes Saturday, had a hard academy session Tuesday, and you're seeing him Thursday. On PlayerPlan, you can see all of that before you programme his session. On TrainHeroic, you're guessing.
4. AI that understands your sport. Ask it to build an MD-3 session for a right-back returning from an adductor issue. It accounts for the injury, the match proximity, the position demands, and pulls from 667 evidence-based coaching insights. TrainHeroic has no AI features.
5. No app required for your players. TrainHeroic requires athletes to download the app, create an account, and set up a profile. PlayerPlan sends a link. Your player opens it in their browser. They see today's session with video demos. They check in wellness. They log their club training. No download, no account, no forgotten passwords at 6:30am in the gym car park.
6. Periodisation that's built in. Base, Build, Peak, Taper, In-Season, Off-Season. Volume targets and intensity zones per week. Deload management. Drag-and-drop programme designer. TrainHeroic doesn't have training phases -- it has blocks of workouts.
7. Protocol management. Injury rehab protocols with player check-ins, compliance tracking, and pain trending. When your midfielder is 6 weeks into a hamstring protocol, you can see exactly where he is and whether he's doing the work. TrainHeroic has nothing for this.
8. A documented API. TrainHeroic has no public API despite it being one of their most frequently requested features. PlayerPlan has documented edge functions for programmatic access. If you want to build integrations or pull data, you can.
The CrossFit Question
It's worth saying plainly: TrainHeroic was built for CrossFit coaches and powerlifting coaches. That's not a criticism -- they serve that market well. But the features that make it great for CrossFit (Metcon logging, daily leaderboards, WOD-style programming) are the same features that make it feel foreign for football S&C.
When a platform's exercise demos, community culture, and feature roadmap are driven by the needs of CrossFit boxes and powerlifting gyms, the football S&C coach is never the priority. You're not the customer they're designing for. You can make it work, but you're constantly working around a tool that doesn't speak your language.
The Verdict
If you coach CrossFit, sell programmes online, or want marketplace exposure and community-driven athlete engagement, TrainHeroic is a strong choice. The marketplace is genuinely compelling, the community features create real engagement, and the expert-authored content shows they care about the craft.
If you're a football S&C coach who programmes around fixture lists, needs to see what your players are doing at club training, tracks load and wellness, manages injury protocols, and wants to hand your players a link instead of making them download another app -- TrainHeroic wasn't built for that. PlayerPlan was.
At 5 players, TrainHeroic is cheaper. At 20, PlayerPlan is cheaper. At every roster size, the feature gap for football S&C is the same: TrainHeroic doesn't have match-day frameworks, periodisation phases, external load tracking, injury protocols, or football-specific AI. The pricing question is secondary to whether the platform actually does the job you need it to do.
Try it free for 30 days -- full Pro access, no credit card.